The benefits fully outweigh any side effect? Bull Shit!
Posted by Raven on 8th July 2008
Headline:
Gardasil certainly made headlines in 2006 when the Food and Drug Administration approved it as a vaccine against four strains of the human papillomavirus, or HPV, which can cause cervical cancer.
HPV can be transmitted sexually, so many parents decided to give the vaccination to their teenaged daughters.
Now, Gardasil is making headlines again. This time, the drug’s manufacturer is under scrutiny as the vaccine’s recipients are complaining of ill side effects.
There have been more than 78,000 complaints about Gardasil, New England Cable News reported Tuesday.
Complaints have included nausea, blood clots, genital warts, paralysis and even death.
The Centers for Disease Control said the deaths are not linked to Gardasil.
Merck is standing by its product, insisting it is safe.
“I think of all the vaccines out there, this has been thoroughly tested prior to release,” said Dr. Manny Alvarez, managing health editor of FOXNews.com. “This is a vaccine that helps protect women from a very deadly disease. Therefore the benefits fully outweigh any side effect that has been found so far.
Now, let’s read between the lines.
HPV is a sexually transmitted disease. It is a virus, which lives on and in the skin of infected persons. There are over 100 different forms of HPV- only 30 or 40 of these are passed around sexually. People who are infected often don’t know it because this is often a asymptomatic disease. Some people will get genital warts. The infection usually clears up within months with no side effects. Sometimes it comes back time after time though. Warts on hands and feet and around mouths are caused by HPV as well.
What about the risks for cervical cancer, the connection with HPV and other factors?
For cervical cancer, the most important risk factor is infection with HPV (human papilloma virus). HPVs are a group of more than 100 types of viruses that cause warts. Some types of HPV cause genital warts. Other types cause cancer of the cervix. These are called “high-risk” HPVs. HPV is passed from one person to another during sex. Having unprotected sex, especially at a young age, makes HPV infection more likely. Also, women who have many sexual partners (or who have sex with men who have had many partners) have a greater chance of getting HPV.
Reading further:
Even though HPV is an important risk factor for cervical cancer, most women with this infection do not get cervical cancer. Doctors believe other factors must come into play for this cancer to develop. Some of these factors are listed below.
Smoking: Women who smoke are about twice as likely as those who don’t to get cervical cancer. Tobacco smoke can produce chemicals that may damage the DNA in cells of the cervix and make cancer more likely to occur.
HIV infection (human immunodeficiency virus): HIV is the virus that causes AIDS (it is not the same as HPV). It can also be a risk factor for cancer of the cervix. Being HIV positive makes a woman’s immune system less able to fight both HPV and early cancers.
Chlamydia (cluh-mid-ee-uh) infection: This is a rather common kind of bacteria that can infect women’s sex organs. It is spread during sex. Many women do not know they have it unless samples taken at the time of their Pap test are looked at for the bacteria. Some studies suggest that women who have this infection (or have had it in the past) are at greater risk for cancer of the cervix. While further studies are needed to find out if this is true, there are good reasons to avoid this infection or to have it treated. Long-term infection can cause other serious problems.
Diet can play a part as well. Diets low in fruits and vegetables are linked to an increased risk of cervical and other cancers. Also, women who are overweight are at a higher risk.
Birth control pills: Long-term use of birth control pills increases the risk of this cancer. Some studies show a higher risk after 5 or more years of use. You should talk to your doctor about the pros and cons of birth control in your own case.Having many pregnancies: Woman who have had many full-term pregnancies have an increased risk of this cancer. No one really knows why this is, but it has been proven beyond doubt by large studies.
Low income: Poor women are at greater risk for cancer of the cervix. This may be because they cannot afford good health care, including Pap tests.
DES (diethylstilbestrol): This drug is a hormone that was used between 1940 and 1971 for some women who were in danger of miscarriages. The daughters of women who took this drug have a slightly higher risk of cancer of the vagina and cervix.
Family history: Recent studies suggest that women whose mother or sister has had cervical cancer are more likely to get the disease themselves. This could be because they are less able to fight off HPV than other women, or other factors could be involved.
So we know there are MANY risk factors associated with cervical cancer. HPV infection is one of them.
Only one- and a small risk at that.
The bottom line here is simple:
Roughly 15,000 women a year are DX with cervical cancer.
Many will catch it in it’s early stages where it can be successfully treated. Life expectancy is high for those who take care of themselves. Remember not all these cancers are caused by HPV…and the women who are DX with this have other risk factors present.
Of the 15,000 women, 3700 will die.
The profile of these women is pretty much the same: She is in her 50’s, smokes, hasn’t had a pap smear in many years; and perhaps her Mother or a sister also has this form of cancer. Maybe she was sexually active in her youth with many different partners.
Gardisal is NOT going to save millions of lives.
78,000 complaints? THIS ISN’T NORMAL. Or expected. Or worth it.
It is totally unethical and disingenuous of Dr Manny of FOX news to pronounce this vaccine as safe AND, to say that the benefits outweigh the risks. Numbers tell a lot. 78,000 side effects, and that is what these complaints ARE, vs. 3700 lives a yr??? Lives caught up in a form of cancer that cannot be absolutely linked (hell, cannot even be closely linked!) to the viruses this vaccine claims to protect against? These side effects are not normal either: Passing out, blindness, seizures??? No. Sore arms, fever, rashes? Yes.
No. Be smart. Listen to your doctor but ask the questions. Print up the linked info and ask for a justification of this.
Posted in Life Counts!, Medical/Nursing, Raven | 2 Comments »

















