When a Family Law Tears Apart Families
Posted by Raven on 9th March 2008
The FMLA is a combination of good and bad, I think. From the perspective of motherhood and having babies…
I remember when my daughters were born- I had worked through each pregnancy right up to the day each was born, literally. Early in each pregnancy I went to Human Resources to tell them of my pending leaves, which I had planned on lasting about four weeks. I was told my job would be safe, probably, and that if not, I would be brought back to a similar position with similar pay and benefit. I managed pretty well- taking the four weeks of leave and returning to the same job in the same unit on the same shift. Had any of these factors changed, especially the SHIFT, I would not have been able to return to the job.
There were no laws protecting jobs back then.
A pro-business group is touting a national survey that says a majority of Americans think the 15-year-old Family and Medical Leave Act needs tightening to eliminate misuse.
The poll by National Coalition to Protect Family Leave, a broad-based group of organizations such as U.S. Chamber of Commerce and National Retail Federation, said that although more than 70 percent of Americans said the current system is “mostly fair,” nearly half of the respondents said they had firsthand experience of misuse by co-workers.
Survey respondents are also concerned about whether the misuse of FMLA would jeopardize public safety. More than 60 percent of people said they would be more likely to support FMLA reform, provided that “the staffing of hospitals is impacted when unscheduled FMLA leave is taken” and “vulnerable citizens, such as children waiting for a school bus or people in need of emergency 9-1-1 services, are left to themselves.”
Now, employers must guarantee the positions will be held for up to 12 weeks, same pay, same status, benefits and no loss in seniority. The problem with this when you work in nursing is fairly big…that’s 12 week of working short. That directly effects patient care. And when you work with a lot of women, this isn’t a rare occurrence.
One year, we had 5 co workers who were pregnant, all within the same time frames, and all of whom took maternity leaves at around the same time. It was a substantial burden to cover their shifts- even with the best pre planning. My employer wasn’t allowed to hire others to fill the open slots; they had to force many others to work overtime or, bring in agency nurses and aides at extremely high pay rates. The Agency option didn’t cover much- since those who work for such places can pick and choose their shifts, we were not able to cover even a tenth of the openings. Women like me, who had little kids at home, were made to work many double shifts and a day off was almost unheard of.
It certainly didn’t feel very FAMILY like to me! In fact my family rarely saw me during those times. Sure the pay was awesome, but nothing can replace being with your kids when they are small. I had to get sitters for the double shifts I was made to work- since my X worked evenings. There went most of my overtime pay…My family suffered because of this law, IMO.
Then, a couple of the new Moms decided they didn’t want to return to work after being at home with their newborn babies. I don’t blame at all- babies are precious and really need their Moms to be with them for the first year if not longer. But, for me and many others, this wasn’t an option in our lives. Needless to say, we had to work another five weeks or so of mandated overtime until the newly hired staff were trained. This scenario played out three other times at the facility I work at. It wasn’t a one time thing.
So I think the law has some good to it…but I also believe it creates a burden not just for the employer, but the employees left behind to pick up the slack. In nursing, the slack is patient care. Is this a case of unintended consequence? When a law designed to *protect* one group of workers infringes upon the lives of another group? The irony of it all is this is about FAMILIES. While one family is allowed to bond and not have to worry about employment, another family is temporarily torn apart due to their employment.
Posted in Life's Lessons, Raven, Work | 3 Comments »



















